Splurge or save … daily makeup

Splurge or Save … daily makeup

MumptyStyle Splurge or Save

Right, so today I thought I would do a “splurge or save” rundown on the standard makeup I use to make up “de ole face.”  

What that means is that I’m going to pretty much go through the makeup that I use on the daily and offer you the “splurge” option and the “save” option.  Something to mention here is that I actually have or had all of these products, so I can make an informed judgement on their performance … which is nice.

If you are one of our Makeup Obsessives, I hope you find this helpful!

So let’s get started …

SPLURGE – Estee Lauder DayWear Plus Moisturiser (around NZ $80)

MumptyStyle Estee Lauder DaywearSAVE – Nivea Soft Moisturising Cream (around NZ $10)

MumpytStyle Nivea Soft

The verdict: while the Estee Lauder product is absolutely gorgeous to apply, honestly the Nivea product does just as good a job, and for $70-odd less, I’m picking the Nivea.

Save: 1, Splurge: 0

SPLURGE – Skindinavia The Makeup Primer Spray (around NZ $50)

MumptyStyle Skindinavia Primer Spray SAVE – ELF Mineral Face Primer – (around NZ $14)

MumptyStyle ELF Primer

The verdict: I’m definitely going to pick the Splurge option here.  The Skindinavia product is just fabulous and your makeup lasts like a dream.  I actually found the ELF product started to give me little pimples – and at my age, I am NOT going there with that!

Save: 1, Splurge: 1

SPLURGE – Estee Lauder Double Wear (around NZ $70)

MumptyStyle EL DoubleWear

SAVE – Natio BB cream (around NZ $20)MumptyStyle Natio BB

The verdict: I kinda had to think about this for a while, and then I realised there was actually no quandary at all – what do I put on my face every day?  It’s the Natio – even though I have the Double Wear too.  In fairness to the Double Wear, I tend to keep it for “going out” and times when I need a fuller coverage, but on a daily basis, it’s the Natio.

Save: 2, Splurge: 1

SPLURGE – Benefit Fakeup (around $45)

MumptyStyle Fakeup

SAVE – Natio Pure Mineral Dark Circle Corrector (around NZ $20)

MumtpyLoves - Natio Dark Circle Corrector

The verdict: I really only wear concealer under the eyes, so I’m going to have to go with the Benefit Fakeup in this case.  The Natio product is magic for hiding and concealing bags and dark circles under the eyes, but I do find it tends to settle in one’s fine laughter lines after an hour or so and the Benefit Fakeup doesn’t do that.  For me anyway.

Save: 2, Splurge: 2

SPLURGE – Lancome Blush Subtil (around NZ $77)

MumptyStyle Lancome blush

SAVE – Jordana blush (around NZ $3.50)

MumptyStyle Jordana blushes

The verdict: I do so love Lancome, but there’s no question here for me.  The Jordana wins hands down – it’s tiny money so you can have a colour to suit every outfit or makeup look – and it’s pretty pigmented as well, so it won’t disappear after five minutes.

Save: 3, Splurge: 2

SPLURGE – Urban Decay Naked 3 palette (not readily available in NZ but can often be bought for around NZ $130)

MumptyStyle Naked 3 palette


SAVE – Chi Chi Nudes palette (around NZ $32)

MumptyStyle Chi Chi Nudes

The verdict: I LOVE my Naked 3 palette with.a.passion and I reach for it every single day.  So yup, it’s the Splurge option on this one.

Save: 3, Splurge: 3

SPLURGE – Estee Lauder (around NZ $85)

MumptyStyle EL Sumptous Extreme mascara

SAVE – Rimmel Scandaleyes Rockin’ Curves mascara (around NZ $20)

MumptyStyle Rimmel mascara

The verdict: I’d probably have to pick the Rimmel Rockin’ Curves here … I will admit the Estee Lauder one is better, but not $65 better, so I’d prefer to save my money on this one.

Save: 4, Splurge: 3

SAVE – Natio Brow Kit (around NZ $26)

MumtpyStyle Natio brow kit
The verdict – I have to admit, I only have this one – I don’t have a splurge option.  However, this is really pretty damm good so I can’t imagine me going out and paying lots for an alternative.  The only thing I might say is that the wax stuff runs out WAY before the colour stuff which is kinda annoying and the only negative I have.

Save: 5, Splurge: 3

SPLURGE – Lime Crime Velvetines (around NZ $32)

MumptyStyle Lime Crime Red Velvet
Red Velvet

SAVE – Australis Velourlips (around NZ $17.50)

MumptyStyle Australis

The verdict – I’m going with the Lime Crime here – I’ve not found a better, more stay-onny option (see my review here.) The Velourlips are good; just not as good.

Save: 5, Splurge: 4

SPLURGE – Benefit The Porefessional Agent Zero Shine Powder (around NZ $58)

Benefit Porefessional MumptyStyle SAVE – ELF High Definition Powder (around NZ $14)

MumptyStyle ELF Powder

The verdict – Agent Zero Shine all the way for me.  I didn’t really like the ELF one at all.

Save: 5, Splurge: 5

Now I don’t always wear eyeliner, but when I have the time and I’m in the mood, these are the ones I have so I might as well include them:

SPLURGE – Benefit Badgal Eyeliner (around NZ $38)

MumptyStyle Benefit Badgal

SAVE – Rimmel Exaggerate Liquid Eyeliner (around NZ $16.50)

MumptyStyle Liquid Eyeliner

The verdict – Most definitely the Rimmel offering.  I found the Benefit one too smudgy and it didn’t offer the precision I was after.

Save: 6, Splurge: 5

So when all is said and done, it appears that I am a cheapskate when it comes to makeup (but only by a whisker!!!)  I SOOO didn’t expect the Save option to come out on top, but I’m secretly pleased it did.  It’s really gratifying to know there are options out there that are far cheaper and that, in many cases, actually do a very similar job to the more expensive versions.

When it comes to your makeup, do you SAVE or do you SPLURGE?

Love …



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s